Dishora - Recipes for a better table
Detroit-Style Double Pepperoni Deep Dish Pizza
GOLD MEDAL: BEST FROZEN PIZZA IN AMERICA
Detroit-Style Double Pepperoni Deep Dish Pizza
β˜… GOLD MEDAL: BEST FROZEN PIZZA IN AMERICAOverall Score: 97/100Best Frozen Pizzas

Detroit-Style Double Pepperoni Deep Dish Pizza

By Motor City Pizza Co.β€’Pack Size: 27.5 oz square pieβ€’Servings: 5 hearty slices

β€œA frozen pizza that legitimately rivals Detroit pizzerias. An impossibly airy, chewy focaccia crust flanked by a crunchy, caramelized cheese frico perimeter.”

Prep Time⏱ 2 mins
Cooking Time♨️ 20 mins
Yield🍽️ 5 hearty slices
CaloriesπŸ”₯ 380 kcal per slice
Detroit style square deep dish pizza with caramelized cheese crust and double pepperoni toppings
Culinary Test Kitchen Seal of Excellence

Detroit style square deep dish pizza with caramelized cheese crust and double pepperoni toppings

Composition & Deck

Ingredients & Elements

  • 1 box Motor City Pizza Co. Detroit-Style Double Pepperoni Pizza (with baking pan)
  • High-hydration focaccia dough (unbleached flour, yeast, olive oil, salt, malted barley)
  • Wisconsin whole-milk brick cheese and shredded mozzarella blend
  • Crushed red tomato sauce (California vine-ripened tomatoes, garlic, oregano, basil)
  • Thick-cut cup-and-char pepperoni curls
  • Traditional flat savory pepperoni slices
  • Fresh basil leaves & hot honey drizzle (recommended serving add-on)
πŸ‘¨β€πŸ³Test Kitchen Chef Tip

Do not bake this pizza on a cookie sheet! The included black pan is engineered to conduct intense dry heat directly from the bottom oven element, turning the bottom crust into golden fried focaccia.

Cooking & Tempering

Preparation Instructions

Bake at 425Β°F for 19-21 minutes inside included pan. Guarantees crispy caramelized frico edges.

Target Oven Temperature: 425Β°F (218Β°C)
1

Preheat Oven & Remove Packaging

Preheat oven to 425Β°F (218Β°C). Remove the pizza from outer cardboard carton and plastic wrapper. Keep the pizza directly inside the included black specialized baking pan.

2

Position Directly on Center Oven Rack

Place the baking pan directly on the center oven rack. Do not place on a baking sheet, as the pan needs direct hot air circulation underneath to fry the bottom crust.

3

Bake to Golden Frico Perfection

Bake at 425Β°F for 19 to 21 minutes. Check that the perimeter cheese is dark caramelized golden brown and the center pepperoni cups have curled with rendered spicy oil.

4

Cool & Slice in Pan

Allow pizza to rest inside the pan for 3 minutes. Use a metal spatula to slide around the edgesβ€”the caramelized cheese will effortlessly release. Transfer to a cutting board and cut into 4 corner slices and 1 center square.

5

Chef's Hot Honey Finish

Drizzle with a tablespoon of hot honey and scatter torn fresh basil leaves across the sizzling pepperonis.

Blind Sensory Panel

Tasting Notes & Flavor Profile

πŸ‘ƒ Aroma

Sizzling browned Wisconsin cheese, smoky cured pepperoni, and freshly baked yeast dough.

πŸ‘… First Bite

Shatteringly crisp golden bottom, pillow-soft focaccia crumb, and savory pepperoni bite.

✨ Mouthfeel & Texture

Chewy, thick, and satisfying; substantial contrast between crispy perimeter and tender center.

🏁 Finish & Aftertaste

Spiced oregano tomato zing and rich savory olive oil notes.

Sommelier & Kitchen Pairings

What to Serve With This Winner

  • ✦Mike's Hot Honey or chili-infused olive oil drizzle
  • ✦Crisp Italian chopped salad with pepperoncini and olives
  • ✦Cold craft IPA or crisp Italian pilsner
The 2026 Freezies

Official Scorecard

97/100
Verified Winner
Taste & Flavor Depth29/30
Texture & Mouthfeel20/20
Ingredient Integrity14/15
Value & Portion Satiety15/15
Convenience & Prep Speed9/10
Culinary Innovation10/10
Editorial Board Tasting Notes

Why This Won The Gold

Most frozen deep dish pizzas are soggy dough bricks with burnt toppings. Motor City's dough achieves a light, airy crumb with cavernous focaccia air pockets. The double pepperoni loading gives you flat savory slices across the cheese bed and thick cup-and-char pepperoni that curls up into crisp grease chalices in the oven.

Evaluated in Blind Kitchen Panel

βœ“ What We Loved

  • β€’Included baking tray produces genuine caramelized cheese crust
  • β€’Airy focaccia dough that avoids dense gumminess
  • β€’Dual pepperoni styles: crispy cups and savory flat slices
  • β€’Outperforms most delivery pizzas at a fraction of the wait

! Things to Keep in Mind

  • β€’Too large and thick for microwave cooking
  • β€’Oven needs a full 425Β°F preheat for proper rise

Nutrition & Dietary Highlights

Calories380 kcal
Protein16g protein
Sodium790mg
Carbohydrates37g
Wisconsin CheeseDetroit Frico CrustCup & Char PepperoniIncluded Pan
Aisle Locator

Where to Buy This Product

πŸ›’ Costco WholesaleπŸ›’ TargetπŸ›’ WalmartπŸ›’ KrogerπŸ›’ MeijerπŸ›’ Sam's Club

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Can this pizza be cooked in a microwave?
No. Detroit-style pizza requires dry convective oven heat to fry the crust and caramelize the outer perimeter cheese.
Q: Can I reuse the included baking pan?
The pan is food-grade and can be reused for baking biscuits, focaccia, or reheating leftover pizza slices.
Verified Taster Feedback

Reader Reviews & Ratings (2)

β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…4.9 out of 5

Have you tasted this frozen award winner? Leave your review

Tony V. (Pizza Enthusiast)β€’ 4 days ago
β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…

I grew up in Detroit eating Buddy's. This is the only supermarket frozen pizza that nails the cheese perimeter crust.

Was this review helpful? πŸ‘ (41)
Samantha K.β€’ 2 weeks ago
β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…

Friday pizza night game changer. Drizzle hot honey on top when it comes out of the oven and you have restaurant quality food.

Was this review helpful? πŸ‘ (26)
More From The Freezies

Explore Other 2026 Gold Winners

All Categories β†’